Search Marin Modus Vivendi

Jan 9, 2008

Glutton for punishment, I guess

Once again, I post to reddit and once again moments later I am down-voted and my previous post is banished forever. So instead, redditers can enjoy the current #1 post:



UPDATE:
  1. I checked my website statistics from last night and found that I had no visitors from reddit. Interestingly, the post I submitted last night has eight down votes and three up votes. 11 people took it upon themselves to vote up or down something that they apparently did not read.
  2. I decided to remove the digg, reddit, and StumbleUpon submit links from the posts. I am not comfortable promoting these services given the data I've seen. Will I still visit these sites? Absolutely. Will it be my primary source of news? No, they serve more as an entertainment diversion than a place to get breaking news. Am I taking my toys home because I can't play well with the other kids? No because...
Marin Modus is my virtual chalkboard. It is a website I put up a few years ago to test out all of the new things coming out in my industry like google adsense, blogs, tracking technologies, and of course, social news. Basically, instead of just reading articles about new trends in online marketing, I need to see them, feel them, etc. so that I can get a strong understanding of it for when my clients ask me "what does X mean or do?" It's been a pretty good self-guided education and the extra benefit is that it only works if I write down my thoughts... needing content on a regular basis to test some of the things (like the true targeting ability of Google Adsense), I have to come up with different topics like the one yesterday or the football rankings (which are great because i can pump out lots of content with the rankings).. I also need site visitors to test things out like Google Analytics to determine how accurate it is. Basically, it's better to test things on my time then my client's time. Having gone through the trials and tribulations of participating in the leading social news communities, I am in a much better place to speak with authority to my clients about when and if they should buy advertising on these sites.

9/30/08 UPDATE: FINALLY! I figured out how to get some karma on Reddit. Last night I posted a timely link from a credible site, www.house.gov, with a provocative title (actually a quote from the piece) that included a statistic that people might find surprising. Stats as of today: 228 points, 257 up votes, 29 down votes. It even made first page for some time. More importantly, my karma went from 1 to 133 over night. I feel like a rock star. Wow. Here is the post.
Glutton for punishment, I guessSocialTwist Tell-a-Friend

Ron Paul and the evolving internet campaign


An internet professional's perspective on the underlying trend Ron Paul's campaign indicates


I have worked in Internet related businesses for my entire career (since 1996). My perspective is skewed by that fact.

In 2000, it was news that John McCain collected $1M in online donations. In 2004, it was news when Howard Dean collected $7M in online donations. Now, in 2008, it is news that Ron Paul collected $20M in online donations. And while it would not surprise me to see a candidate collect $50M+ in 2012, this exponential increase in donations is really only part of the story.

Let's first look at the data of media consumption by different age groups. The chart below shows media usage by different age groups to find information about companies or products [ed note: and presumably, candidates]. As you can see, there is a 50% jump in usage of the internet by people aged 18-31 vs baby boomers aged 42 to 62. Conversely, Newspapers, Broadcast TV, and Magazines register significantly lower for people aged 18-31 vs. those aged 42-62. Gen Xers also rate highly for internet consumption. It should be noted that those 62+, which make up more than 20% of voters (see below), register in the mid-teens for overall internet usage and even lower for research oriented usage.



In 2004 (according to the US Census), the voter turnout for those aged 45+ was 71%. The turnout for people aged 25-44 was only 52% and only 42% turnout for those aged 18-24. The 45+ age group comprises 57% of voters. By virtue that voters are older, broadcast TV, newspapers, magazines and cable TV continue their impact on elections. But as the digital population grows older and becomes more involved in elections, the internet becomes ever more important to election outcomes. The fact that the Internet rates #1 for all segments is very interesting and indicative of a generational, but probably slow moving change, that will likely be reflected more and more in subsequent elections because...

There has been much hay made of Ron Paul's popularity in Social Networks like Facebook, YouTube, and most importantly, Meetup which has brought online people to the offline world. Look at these numbers below showing social network usage for teens (aka the next generation of voters). By 2012, more than 84% of teens will be using Social Networks at least once per month. These are the same teens who are nowhere to be found on TV and not reading newspapers. Ron Paul's 1200+ meetup groups may represent the future of grassroots organization for both national and local political campaigns.



The next set of data shows that 53% of kids aged 3 to 17 will be on social networks at least once per month. A drop-off from the teenager numbers cited above, but still considerable. From the cradle, children are going to be trained that the internet is an access point to a world of interaction, social connections, organization and massive amounts of information.



And, most importantly, they will not be locked to their desks. Kids today are accessing the internet through a multitude of devices that will make it easier to mobilize, organize, communicate and coordinate. Just like Toyota's just in time supply management, the campaign of the future will have just in time campaign coordination. People wondered how Ron Paul supporters could be everywhere when they thought there were so few of them. It was because of constant communication via email, mobile and video platforms that the people can be on the move.



What I find interesting about this next graphic is that proactively communicating and finding information are the top 7 most popular internet activities while reactively consuming news is only #8. People who use the internet control their own destiny and control their content. According to a 2007 Comscore study, the average broadband user views 126+ internet pages per day. Google is the US's number one website with 131M monthly visitors. Wikipedia is #8 with 55M monthly visitors. The user is in control and not going to cede that control to anyone.



John McCain in 2000, Howard Dean in 2004 and Ron Paul in 2008 are proving that there is a way to compete with (and now beat) the massive donations some campaigns receive from different interest groups. The masses are showing that they can organize online to mobilize offline. And if the statistics above are correct, information flow should be much freer and more fluid.

Even though I griped about social news users in my previous post, there is real value in alternative sources of news and information like digg, reddit and Google News. And with sites like Facebook and Wikipedia continuing momentum, the consumer (and voter) is bound to get more empowered.

Yes, overall I am optimistic. Ron Paul placed 5th last night and that is OK with me. I suppose to me, and probably many other Ron Paul fans, I was drawn by his specific policy surrounding Iraq and US Imperialism, approved or tolerated his other positions, but was (and still am) most inspired by the grassroots campaigning on the internet.

This campaign is showing the change what we can all expect in the future. We all need to work hard to see it happen, but it is clear that the way the majority of the voters get their information today and the way they get it in the future will be much different. And that is a reason to be optimistic, thankful and happy about the election so far.

UPDATE: Barack Obama's online fundraising has completely smashed my expectations. Incredible. More importantly has been his embrace of customer relationship management best practices and engaging his audience in an interactive discussion. Great work.
Ron Paul and the evolving internet campaignSocialTwist Tell-a-Friend

Jan 3, 2008

Why social news bugs me

Social news is supposedly about democratizing news information by letting users vote up or down stories. The promise is that mainstream media or ruthless media moguls will not be able to control the flow of information anymore. The concept is quite interesting but the execution is not.

I just submitted, what I thought, was an interesting post regarding an ad campaign that Michael Bloomberg is running on Gmail. Within seconds, my post had been down-voted on reddit and banished away forever. On the other hand, the current second "hottest" post on reddit is:



Which leads to this paragraph: "New information has been released regarding the sperm whale that came into the mouth of Tampa Bay over the weekend."

News, indeed.

The question: Do I eliminate my links to Digg, Reddit and others in protest? I will lose a lot of traffic... hmm.
Why social news bugs meSocialTwist Tell-a-Friend